Yes, similar players. I agree with your suggestions except in 2 points: DS & MENT. Firstly, DS, he can do long runs at an amazing speed with the ball near his feet, also with an excellent AGI. I don't see it in a not-yellow value. And MENT 78 may be a bit exaggerated, it's true that he has scored goals in adverse situations, but they were more due to his football conditions rather than will and spirit. In fact, is one of those players who can really disappear from the match, yesterday against Central was a clear example, didn't appear in any moment. I don't mind putting him a green value but not greater than 76.
Good incorporation for SMSJ. Anyways taking a look into the current ATT ladder for AMFs, I think the current value with which I updated some months ago has became high. I mean, he's over Caneo for example, and he isn't half as consistent/dangerous as Miguel or other AMs lately. Maybe a decrease could be analysed in the future, so he has brilliant matches only from times to times (let's say, when he's "red arrowed" ingame). Up to date, the value is high IMO.