Mentality should be his top stat, thats clear. Do you think he should be the no1 in the league about MENT?
Balance and jumping are next and maybe stamina.
Defence is on white values for me
I use to rate players arranging their stats in 2 groups.
There are stats that are usefull for any player and you can see often more than 70s 80s like speed stats, stamina
And stats that you can recognise quality by players like Attack, Defence, Responce, Dribble Accuracy, Short Pass Accuracy/speed, Shoot Accuracy.