Dolfar wrote:Taking into account height is not redundant at all, the over all package of a players ability to head a ball includes height among others already mentioned above aswell.
Dolfar wrote:You think the brief list of players I made above are so prolific with their head that it warrants them having these stats? Defensive heading is a different animal to accurate goal scoring ability with the head, if he's going to be handicapped because you're idea of a player's heading ability is based on a defenders goal tally at the end of a season then I guess we should leave it as is... You're being ridiculous!
Dolfar wrote:Everton play to their strengths on set pieces and aim for Cahill, Fellaini and Saha, for this reason alone, Jagielka doesn't often score.
Dolfar wrote:As for the so called clanger at villa, are you referring to the own goal he scored when he was pushed in the air by Carew? Hardly a moment to compare his heading ability...
Dolfar wrote:Try playing with him in-game with the current stats and tell me he's dominant, he's nothing of the sort.
You make it sound like i'm asking for the world... i'm asking for an increase in heading because I believe that Jagielka is better than Mancienne at heading a ball. I would say he's on par with Toure.Look at the ladder and look who's on top, Vidic and Terry, they're there because they're able to pass the ball with their head and place a ball perfectly
They're more prolific, no? I don't even know how you can utter Phil's name in the same vein as some of the players you've compared him to:
Vermaelen, G. Cahill, Ryan Nelson, K. Toure, S. Taylor, Upson, Craddock, Gallas, Dawson
All of these players are leapyears ahead of Jags in regards to heading, don't deny it, can you honestly say he's better than one or even on par?
Because they're the players who're adept at challenging arially, no?
Phil wrote:Regarding an update this is what I'd change:
Dribble Acc: 72
Short Pass Acc: 74
Long Pass Acc: 75/76
Free Kick Acc: 68 (has he ever even taken a free-kick ?)
Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 2 guests