by Mateo » 2011 Sep 04, 17:09
OK, so let's start:
Positions - While he was younger, he was much more playing as a CMF then DMF. But that was then. During past seasons, the Hajduk's formation was always changed, and he was (almost) always playing somewhat deep position, that is DMF. I don't think he's playing the same position as Badelj for example. And I'll add CB to his registered.
Injury Tolerance - He's a B definitely. Last season he didn't played much games as he always had those little injuries.
Side - It might be just a "cosmetic" value, PES puts N/A when you choose mid positions.
Attack - Don't know really, he mostly relies on his SP when attacking.
Defence - Agree.
Balance - Agree.
Stamina - Agree.
Top Speed & Acceleration - I'd rather have him on 77/75 or 76/74.
Agility - I'd prefer 76, but don't have nothing against 75.
Dribble Accuracy - Agree.
Dribble Speed: 76/75 - This should be also lowered together with his speed.
Passing - I don't see any reason to increase his short passing as he's just average in it. For long passing, I don't think he's that bad to be in range of CB's.
Shot Technique - With 76 he'd be on pair with Sammir, I'd go for 72/73.
Free Kick Accuracy - Agree, he hasn't scored any of them over a year.
Curling - It still could be 75.
Header - It still could be 77.
Jump - Agree, but I'm not 100 % sure as it's drastic raising.
Aggression - Agree, he's not going forward like before anymore.
Mentality - 88 puts him on pair with Senna, Schweinsteiger, Bullard, Gerrard... I'd go for 86 as I see him like this: Makoun (87) > Andric (86) > Alou Diarra (85).
Teamwork - I'd go for 82, don't see him on pair with Biscan.
Condition/Fitness - As I said for Injury already, 6 with B replicates his little injuries and few bad games per season.
And what about giving him Enforcer?
----------------------
With all of that said, we mostly share the same opinion about some values, but it concerns me some big differences like ST, Jump and Mentality. If your values are at least 90 % correct, then I should do a re-updating for (almost) all players of Dinamo and Hajduk.
MocaBG: "I am the only one here that is folowing our football and who knows to rate players corectly!" LOL