Jason Puncheon

[antony]

[BigStu]

Pretty good, sure things probably need tweaking here and there but as a base a very good start, Ill leave them in old format for now untill we get a few tweaks done

[čale]

apart from the overrated ATT, DEF, STA and Speed the set looks quite good, i'd just bump his DA by a few points to something like 84, lower RES to low 70's, slightly increase SPA and give him a nice bump in LPA as he really does have a nice cross on him and lower MENT and TW to low 70's. As for the ones which i said i believe to be overrated i'd go with:

ATT - 73
DEF - 48
STA - 77
TS - 80
ACC - 83

[Jez]

His goal in the League Cup.

[the sloth]

I was pretty impressed with him against MU.

I noted that he is a good crosser and I could see his LPA going to high green or 80. I thought he was a solid short passer and was surprised to see him on whites here for SPA.

I thought he seemed more dangerous than the 73 that cale suggested but maybe this was just a good game for him. Other than that, cale has cover my thoughts already.

[BigStu]

it was a red arrow game for him, he never impressed much apart from as an inpact sub on loan spells

[vinnie]

he can't possibly be 85 AGI can he? he turns and moves stiffly, like he's got a log up his ass. 79-80 is my brief estimate, maybe a tad harsh, the range could be extended by two either way, but am i wrong? i'd like to see some examples of 85 AGI, because he showed none of it against arsenal in all his dribbling runs and movements. Doesn't seem like he's physically capable of even turning that quick, he has a weird build, like Hulk kind of. For example there was a counter after another bad clearance by szczesny straight to one of the Southampton mids, sent him down to the corner, and he just about fell over trying to turn 45 degrees unchallenged, the sort of really stiff forced movements. I highly doubt he's more then 80 AGI at most.

His dribbling stats seem nice atm though, same with TEC, pretty accurately rated in these aspects.


*Edit: I seriously doubt he's more then 78 AGI even, he's got no range of movement or fluidity, all rigidity and a highly limited range of movement....

[the sloth]

From what I have seen of him and admittedly I haven't seen much of him, he doesn't display that 85 AGI value. Hadn't noticed before that it was that high. The range of 78-79 seems to fit better.

Hopefully Stu will chime in on this.

Edit: Really great to see you contributing to the less well known teams and players, vinnie.

[vinnie]

Missed the first half of the game but again he really didn't show any agility in his movements, he moves in series of movements rather then showing fluidity, from how I'd rate it the 80's I'd estimated previously is generous, simply out of a bit of respect I witheld and reconsidered the extent of my contrasting opinion, but I haven't seen any example of agility over low-mid greens.

It'd be great if Jez or Stu, anyone that knows him well can show me otherwise, because it's a stark contrast I have with this set's agility.

Thanks btw sloth, already know how great you are for the lesser sung teams.

[MaxPower]

He had a great game today against Villa. He was probably upped with red arrows though.

[Alexalibur]

Showed decent control on the ball tonight.

[MaxPower]

He has had good performances (when he wants to; sometimes he's a ghost on field).

Showed decent control on the ball tonight.

I agree. Sure, Gastón has a better Ball Control (84), but Puncheon isn't that far. I'd suggest Ball Control 81-82.

[R10]

He has had good performances (when he wants to; sometimes he's a ghost on field).

Showed decent control on the ball tonight.

I agree. Sure, Gastón has a better Ball Control (84), but Puncheon isn't that far. I'd suggest Ball Control 81-82.

any value Puncheon has, Gaston is 5 points over that in ball control.
STA 77 looks ok, he ran like crazy for 30 mins, than he was nowhere in second half.

[MaxPower]

STA 77 looks ok, he ran like crazy for 30 mins, than he was nowhere in second half.

Who was talking about Stamina before??

[R10]

noone, I just made a statement that can be taken into account when next time he is updated

[Alexalibur]

He has had good performances (when he wants to; sometimes he's a ghost on field).

Showed decent control on the ball tonight.

I agree. Sure, Gastón has a better Ball Control (84), but Puncheon isn't that far. I'd suggest Ball Control 81-82.

I was actually referring to his DA. Sorry.