Benoît Costil

[anonyme]

[nonobus]

Aren't you a bit too enthusiatic with his stats ? I don't know him enough to rate him correctly, but Def:85(same as Douchez?) -Agi:84 - Res:90 -Gks:85 makes him the best Gk in ligue 1 after Lloris,Mandanda,and Carrasso.
He seems quite fast and easy to do great saves, but same Response as Ruffier, better than Ospina or Carrasso ? Is his handling of the ball that good and secure to have Gks:85 ?

[anonyme]

Yes I'm really bad to make goalkeaper. They are some values that I don't understand for goalkeaper (GK and Def)

His style is like Lloris, he remember me a lot him so I use he set of Lloris to help me.

May be GK and Def down to 83, what do you think?

[anonyme]

Updated:

Def: 83
BB: 84
Agi: 83
GK: 83

[nonobus]

The keepers are difficult to rate, because the difference between a good keeper and an excellent one is in fact quite little. Here is what i learned about Goalkeepers:
Defence stat stands for their positionning in the goals facing a shot(how often and how well they are on the target to stop a shot, the quality of their steps when facing a striker who is going to shot.
GkS stat stands for the quality of the gk's handling(his catching of ball, for instance Landreau is very average at it, because he often punched the ball instead of catching it and sometimes make big handling mistakes).
As for Costil he's doing a very good start of the season, but he hasn't played enough in first division to be considered better as many ligue 1 keepers, i think.
You already decreased some of his stats, but i would also decrease his RES to RES:88.
I' ll try to watch him play more often to have a better idea of his abilities.

[anonyme]

Thanks

updated response to 88

[conker8]

I notice Costil is really good with his feet - I would suggest to increase SP to 85-86 (top of the ladder) : similar to Douchez.

[anonyme]

You can update his SP with this value