Weird, the only ones with DF Leader in Nacional B are Goux and Furios; and Macaluso, Cajaravilla, León, Marmol, Goux again and Cristian Leiva have Man Marking. I think that probably unless Leiva and León (according to what I could see lately), the rest can be fine. I really don't know deeply the situation of Marmol
EDITED:
GOALKEEPERS RATINGSAccording to the new ways of rating Gks, I've made a ladder on the GKs I believe I know enough. You can see the explanations of these new "standards" that are being applied
here, based on s-cobar work. I'll update with these numbers, then you can say if you see something which isn't appropiate in your opinion, argue and change if necessary. Most of the GKs here are good but only on reflexes, few of them have a really good control of situations and their box. Notice that the main stats that define how good a GK is are DEF (mainly)/RESP/KS, while some stats we previously rated as important, are not really (AGI/MENT/JUMP) and have to be rated as any other field player
DEFENSE:84 Julio CHIARINI
8382 Mario VEGA
81 Fernando MONETTI, Carlos BOSSIO
80 Gastón SESSA, Emanuel TRÍPODI
79 Federico CRIVELLI, Fernando PELLEGRINO, José Luis MARTÍNEZ GULLOTA, Josué AYALA, Leandro CHICHIZOLA, Lucas ISCHUK, Matías VEGA, Pablo PERAFÁN, Sebastián BERTOLI, Lucas CALVIÑO, Manuel GARCÍA, Maximiliano CAVALLOTTI, Pablo CAMPODÓNICO, Jorge BROUN
78 Matías GIORDANO, Nicolás TAUBER
77 Carlos DE GIORGIS, Sebastián PEREYRA
RESPONSE84 Gastón SESSA, Julio CHIARINI, Mario VEGA
83 Emanuel TRÍPODI, Fernando MONETTI, Fernando PELLEGRINO, Jorge BROUN, Leandro CHICHIZOLA, Sebastián BERTOLI, Maximiliano CAVALLOTTI, Pablo PERAFÁN
82 Carlos BOSSIO, Federico CRIVELLI, José Luis MARTÍNEZ GULLOTA, Josué AYALA, Lucas CALVIÑO, Lucas ISCHUK, Manuel GARCÍA, Matías GIORDANO, Matías VEGA, Pablo CAMPODÓNICO
81 Sebastián PEREYRA, Nicolás TAUBER
80 Carlos DE GIORGIS
I've tried lower values than yellows in RESP on some GKs and it makes them really harsh and almost look amateur ingame. As s-cobar wrote, reflexes are the first thing a goalkeeper learn, so except very exaggerate cases, they should be always above 80 (even 80 is a weak value)
AGILITY79 Fernando MONETTI
78 Julio CHIARINI, Leandro CHICHIZOLA
77 Lucas CALVIÑO
76 Josué AYALA, Pablo PERAFÁN
75 74 Nicolás TAUBER
73 Carlos DE GIORGIS, Federico CRIVELLI, Manuel GARCÍA, Maximiliano CAVALLOTTI
72 71 Matías VEGA, Mario Daniel VEGA, Emanuel TRÍPODI
70 Lucas ISCHUK
69 Fernando PELLEGRINO, Gastón SESSA, José Luis MARTÍNEZ GULLOTA, Jorge BROUN
68 67 Matías GIORDANO, Sebastián BERTOLI
66 Pablo CAMPODÓNICO, Carlos BOSSIO
MENTALITY83 Gastón SESSA
82 Carlos BOSSIO
81 Pablo CAMPODÓNICO
80 Pablo PERAFÁN
79 Emanuel TRÍPODI, Fernando PELLEGRINO,
78 Nicolás TAUBER, Jorge BROUN
77 Sebastián BERTOLI, Federico CRIVELLI, Fernando MONETTI, Mario VEGA, Julio CHIARINI, Josué AYALA, Matías GIORDANO, Sebastián PEREYRA
76 Lucas CALVIÑO, Maximiliano CAVALLOTTI, Carlos DE GIORGIS
75 Manuel GARCÍA, Matías VEGA, José Luis MARTÍNEZ GULLOTA,
74 Leandro CHICHIZOLA
As said, notice that Mentality is rated here as in any other player. Players who are "leaders", who deal better with pressure and adverse situations deserve good values. Previously we rated it believing it was "
the decision to go out" and cut crosses or reducing opponents' shooting angles, for example; now we know that
that is Aggresion and always depending on DEF.
I'm pending on KS and AGG ratings, I hope to watch better and post up the changes soon. The goalkeepers in the database missing in my ladders are: Gastón MONZÓN, Silvio DULCICH, César TABORDA, Gastón LOSA, Rodrigo LLINÁS, Darío CAPOGROSSO, Mauro Ignacio RUGGIERO, Pablo BANGARDINO and César MONASTERIO. If anyone knows 'em and would like to suggest, you're welcome.
I'll update with these values this evening if possible,
NT) will be both well rated at something like 70 IMO. I'll try ingame and then say my conclussions.
