Marco Reus

[calleklein]

[Vodoved]

Not "Oh my god I worked so hard on this set, someone has a differnt opinion on something that needs to be changed... do whatever you want I gave up!" Seriously wtf.

+1
I would said the same thing but my english is not so good

[s-cobar]

man honestly, the set was nice at all. It wa shigher in the past and we had a lot of discussions in the chat that he`s overrated with that. Also take a view at Adieets set in the alt section - it`s even lower rated in different points

[Alexalibur]

I suggest that you update the set with adieet's and use it as a benchmark, or use Konami's. BTW Is Konami's set a good one?

[s-cobar]

there is no Konami set - and I talk with Adieet via PM about some things

[BigStu]

maybe I've misread but just giving a player all 50's caus no one can agree is pathetic

[mracho]

Exactly... can anyone put the set back?

[Mr. Evans]

What's all this hostility? Can't people just act civilized towards each other and simply discuss stats without anyone's feelings getting hurt? This is so stupid.

[xeneize]

somebody can put his last set again? if i¡'m not wrong had this numbers

Spoiler: show

Attack: 81
Defence: 47
Balance: 79
Stamina: 84
Top Speed: 87
Acceleration: 84
Response: 83
Agility: 84
Dribble Accuracy: 81
Dribble Speed: 84
Short Pass Accuracy: 78
Short Pass Speed: 75
Long Pass Accuracy: 77
Long Pass Speed: 75
Shot Accuracy: 79
Shot Power: 85
Shot Technique: 77
Free Kick Accuracy: 70
Curling: 79
Header: 70
Jump: 75
Technique: 79
Aggression: 90
Mentality: 77
Keeper Skills: 50
Teamwork: 80

Condition/Fitness: 6
Weak Foot Accuracy: 5
Weak Foot Frequency: 5

SPECIAL ABILITIES:

PLAYER INDEX CARDS:
P04
P09
P15
S01
S05
S06
S15

[s-cobar]

I`ll give him an update tomorrow... try to figure out something

[Yazid]

Wtf is this shit? This forum is so pathetic sometimes. Why don't we work together on a decent set rather than one person making a set and rejecting ideas from others.

[antoniolaz]

Okay guys, I don't really know what exactly has to be changed. But with this set he is a completely average player except of his Aggression.

I mean, he's played a great season. The second half wasn't that terrible either. I think this set is just too bad.

[s-cobar]

he didn`t played a great season, he played a great first half - a terrible second half and it was his first season where he was outstanding for some time. he has to prove himself at Dortmund and on an international level. I´m really sick of raise players cause they were good at the BL against small teams. there is much more needed than good performances against some BL teams to be rated on an international level.

[Alexalibur]

I think it's more of a MENT/Form issue here, he's still young and needs more experience at some stages, and we can't really judge him as a great player; a promising prospect would be a better option. Also, he got bad when the whole Monchengladbach team didn't perform well. I'd rather stay with those stats (I'd put him on 82 RES TBAFB) And the rest looks good from what I've seen.

[s-cobar]

honestly I´ve him on Att 78 in my OF, on a lower res - ment somewhere in the low 70s but it wouldn`t fit at all in here. also I´m definitely against ts over acc - but it`s a new trend on PSD to rate everyone with a higher ts than acc. I can`t understand why it`s so often that we create new trends - like in the past to rate every player with a great height on a high ts and low acc. still kill individualism, same like before just a trend where all are follow

[Alexalibur]

Green Attack sounds like a reasonable number to me, and I don't think it'll be a perfect idea to go very low with his RES, it won't make him as good as he really is. He can be effective, and some of the chances/goals he created because his timing was right.

If it kill individualism, why do you keep it? You shouldn't allow people to influence such things. If you (or any other member, respect) gave them the green light, many sets will be ruined. Just put what you see right, and a discussion might prove it either deserved or not

[Kruger13]

maybe I've misread but just giving a player all 50's caus no one can agree is pathetic

You didn't misread and It isn't pathetic.

What's all this hostility? Can't people just act civilized towards each other and simply discuss stats without anyone's feelings getting hurt? This is so stupid.

No. We can't. I find your endowed ALt Sec stupid.

honestly I´ve him on Att 78 in my OF, on a lower res - ment somewhere in the low 70s but it wouldn`t fit at all in here. also I´m definitely against ts over acc - but it`s a new trend on PSD to rate everyone with a higher ts than acc. I can`t understand why it`s so often that we create new trends - like in the past to rate every player with a great height on a high ts and low acc. still kill individualism, same like before just a trend where all are follow

It isn't a trend. Reus is the kind of player that becomes faster over distance and to represent this he needs lower ACC than TS. Maybe the gap is a bit high, it can be closer or even both values at same level, problably an 86 TS and 86 ACC. Talking about his RES, i like current value. Imo - he is a TECH<DA kind of player, his first touch isn't too classy so that's why he showed some control and carrying problems with ball at his feet. With "high" response he recovers from that control/technique problems and retake ball again as he does in real life. Also, another minor tweaks that can be consider are SA: 81 and ATT: 83.

*Btw, it is missing Maraunding, Outside Curve and 1-Touch Play cards.

[jurgens]

I just wanna say a few things. I think he is quite hard to rate, as I said... sloppy at many aspects of his game so it makes it hard to rate him. But if were talking about his passing, I think due to his vision he needs a heightend SPA, 80 imo. Also his placement is pretty good too, wouldn't object to a higher raise now that we've properly established how to rate SA.. something like the original 83 wouldn't be bad, I'd like to see him starting instead of podolski..imo hes more fitting.

[čale]

agree here as well, but i'd like to note that he's got a lot of problems with pulling decent shots while under pressure, but when unmarked he can be simply deadly.

EDIT: oops...didn't saw that the thread was locked...

[anonyme]

Make a good games yesterday. Good surprise for me.

[jurgens]

this is unlocked btw