Anatoliy Tymoshchuk

[Helios]

[jmg721]

Me and Re wrote a bunch back and forth about Response for CMF in the old thread...but filtering out and leaving just suggestions, this is what I am left with:

I believe that Tymoschuk is in the elite class of "Response" in a central midfielder. I realize that this also will improve his tackling ability as he is a DMF. But I think he is the definition of understanding the game, and reacting to counterattacks. IMO, possibly only Cambiasso should be ahead.

I'm not suggesting a value at this time, as the whole scale needs to be set..but I feel when all is said and done, he should possibly be near the 90 mark.

Re: 86
I agree that Cambiasso should get 90, but 93 is just too much, I gave Makelele 87, Lampard 85/86, Donadel and Ledesma 85, Vieira 84, Gerrard 86. I'd also give 87 to Gattuso. World class starts for me from 85, I'm generally not a fan of this so called God region, because it makes player a head over others, Cambiasso reactions are purely phenomenal, but is he better than Rio or Nesta, I don't think so.

Okay, so based on where all the other CMF's responses go...I am suggesting a value 86-88 range.

It looks like Makalele is sticking at 90 for the time being, and that means Cambiasso will probably stick at 92/93. So I am leaning towards 88 for Tymoschuk.

[FDA192]

Totally agreed. Tymoshchuk is absolutely world class in that aspect of the game, and I'm sad that he isn't playing in a bigger league than the Russian one. Would love to see him do his thing at a big European club, as he would no doubt succeed there.

[PMC]

well Bayern Munich knocked on his door already

[fillerup]

i agree w/ 88 response.

hope bayern gets him. this guy is WAY better than mark van bommel, and he will provide the defensive quality needed from the DMs

[jmg721]

Any more thoughts on Response. I truely feel that on the general ladders for this site, and the "Response Revolution" an 88 fits Tymoschuk.

[Helios]

Any more thoughts on Response. I truely feel that on the general ladders for this site, and the "Response Revolution" an 88 fits Tymoschuk.

I think you're spot on.

Any objections before I change this value ? Speak now or forever hold your peace !

[Markulur]

Go with it!!

[Snoggins]

Too high stamina, no doubt that Tima is made by steel.. But it is not 95, 92 - not more. And he is not so agile with dribbling speed, 80 is too high. I think he must have about 72-73.

[Softy]

Joining Bayern in the summer, great move from Bayern, sore loss for Zenit.

[Paddy]

Too high stamina, no doubt that Tima is made by steel.. But it is not 95, 92 - not more. And he is not so agile with dribbling speed, 80 is too high. I think he must have about 72-73.

what do you think Helios

[Re-arranged]

Agility 76 is ok, could be even slightly higher. As for stamina it's all about personal taste, I'd prefer having it at 94-95, but someone might find it a bit high.

[Paddy]

Good to see you re. Just wondering what FK style does he use?

[dahaw]

I Think 8, like Lampard

[Paddy]

thanks.

[Helios]

what do you think Helios

The stats in the first post are fine.

[Minell]

he can moved to bayern münchen

[dahaw]

I Think he is overrated, with those stats he is one of the best MDFs in the game

[calleklein]

I think the same too.
But better we wait and see...

[Kubbas]

I would add Centre star, but so far so good, great stats.