He tracks back quite a bit and packs quite an accurate tackle, I'd personally have him on 44.
Andy is a tank and challenges nearly everyone and certainly isn't as weak as this. He should have a value of 86.
Dribble Speed: 74
He doesn't lose that much pace on the ball.
Has both a great jump and header, both defensively and offensively I'd give him an 84 for Header and a value of...
81 for Jump.
He makes a lot of attacking runs and gets forward a lot more than an 82 would suggest.
Whenever I've seen him he tracks back, challenges players and carries on throughout the game. He give's his all every game and could easily warrant a 10 point jump in Mentality.