I read above that Chumpitaz deserved Red for defence, in terms of ladders I would have to agree though he was not behind Figueroa as the best South American Defender of all time but Jose Santamaria also.
n terms of their overall game, My Top 10 All Time South American defenders.
Domingo Da Guia
So does he deserve a RED? Which is reserved for the all time greats? Who else is better in World Football Legend from around the world excluding South America?
Beckenbauer? Baresi? Bobby Moore? DeSailly? Scirea? Nesta? Cannavaro? I am looking at his rating now, 94 is where I'm at the moment.
Beckenbauer, Moore, Baresi are in a class of their own. ***
Looked on the site at defensive ratings...
Beckenbauer - 93
Santamaria - 93
Passarella - 94
Moore - 95
Desailly - 90
Figueroa - 97
Baresi - 98
Scirea - 94
Considering the subjective nature of stat making, my Hector seems to have a good defense rating. He could come up to 94 and someone nudge Passarella down to 93 or keep Passarella the same after all it's 1 point. Looking at the stats the ratings for the greats I would say someone needs to nudge Moore and Santamaria up! I think Chumpitaz moving from 92-94 is a good move and will be done. Chumpitaz was a great player but not RED as in Moore, Baresi, Figueroa, Cannavaro and I think Nesta whose stats I could not link to. Santamaria is under rated on this site.***
zguc wrote:My opinion is that DEF certainly should be 94 if not 95, as far as RES I would not go with the value in red I think his DEF to be greater than RES, the current value seems small, but it certainly deserves a 92/93.
Jump was also his strong arms but I would not have given him such great value that I would'd put about 90/91
Have raised DEF 92 > 94 and Response 90 > 92
Chumpitaz great as he was is not a RED.