Moderators: Gugu, BigStu, Jez, vinnie, Mod's
blackzidane wrote:technique should be between 79-80 max.
no way is he more adept at controlling a ball over Merida, Rui Fonte or Jack Wilshere...IMO this player is highly overrated....
SPA could be dropped to a 77 his short passing game is sub par at best, he has a better long passing range than short.
That being said, team work should be dropped a few points as well. Again I'm thinking the 75-77 range

GoonerLover66 wrote:With Technique, I agree, but the rest of your post is total rubbish.
His short passing game is superb for a guy of his age, his accurarcy within his short passes. At both Cardiff and Arsenal he has trained in short passing triangles and is quite a formidable force when it comes to the speed and accuracy of these passes. Of course, his long passing game is his main quality, but to say that his short passing is sub-par is total rubbish. There was due reason for him being dubbed "the Next Fabregas"
And I can't understand your Team Work suggestion. His understanding with his team-mates is decent, at Cardiff and in the Welsh team he has proved this, providing passes a move or two ahead of the game. His Team Work stat is quite representative of his vision, which alongside his long passing abilities, is a huge part of his game!
There's only a few faults I can find in the first post, and that's his LPS (which I reckon should be higher as his long passes can amass some distance and can be hit with some ferocity) and possibly his Balance (He's showing his physical strength more in the Reserves, and has been able to contest some physical battles when he has been played in the holding role).
blackzidane wrote:GoonerLover66 wrote:With Technique, I agree, but the rest of your post is total rubbish.
His short passing game is superb for a guy of his age, his accurarcy within his short passes. At both Cardiff and Arsenal he has trained in short passing triangles and is quite a formidable force when it comes to the speed and accuracy of these passes. Of course, his long passing game is his main quality, but to say that his short passing is sub-par is total rubbish. There was due reason for him being dubbed "the Next Fabregas"
And I can't understand your Team Work suggestion. His understanding with his team-mates is decent, at Cardiff and in the Welsh team he has proved this, providing passes a move or two ahead of the game. His Team Work stat is quite representative of his vision, which alongside his long passing abilities, is a huge part of his game!
There's only a few faults I can find in the first post, and that's his LPS (which I reckon should be higher as his long passes can amass some distance and can be hit with some ferocity) and possibly his Balance (He's showing his physical strength more in the Reserves, and has been able to contest some physical battles when he has been played in the holding role).
That's your opinion mate. Please refrain from calling my views "rubbish" as they are my views. I personally think his stats are overrated because he plays for Arsenal and the media has dubbed him "the next Fabregas" Without him ever putting in a decent shift where he doesn't fade out of a game after the first 30 minutes. He's still young and by the time he's maybe 19 or even by next year those stats may be justified with his performances on the pitch, but as of right now he is very overrated.

GoonerLover66 wrote:Yes, I was harsh to call them rubbish. But the fact that he's fading in and out of games is not reflective of his technical abilities at all and that's a Mentality and a Consistency issue. But I disagree about saying that he hasn't put in decent shifts, he definitely put in a full 90 minutes worth at Cardiff and in the few games he has played for Wales. He may not be doing it regularly as such. But using the word "ever" is just harsh as me using the word "rubbish".
And I find it funny that you've said that he's only been given those stats because he's at Arsenal, because the stats were actually made when he was still at Cardiff
TheTrueSeto wrote:I've yet to see him misplace a pass and they aren't just 5 yarders so his passing stats are fine
quincy_huang wrote:TheTrueSeto wrote:I've yet to see him misplace a pass and they aren't just 5 yarders so his passing stats are fine
agree here
does anyone think his repsonse should be higher?
the match he played against aston villa show he isnt slow with reaction..

GoonerLover66 wrote:quincy_huang wrote:TheTrueSeto wrote:I've yet to see him misplace a pass and they aren't just 5 yarders so his passing stats are fine
agree here
does anyone think his repsonse should be higher?
the match he played against aston villa show he isnt slow with reaction..
That seems fair, the stats were made before the Response revolution. But the most I'd give him at the moment is a 78/79, he still mistimes his tackles.
I've also made some general changes in LPS and Balance.




Brezza wrote:Gary Neville is the reason why he didn't come to Man Utd![]()
![]()





Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 0 guests