David Silva

[Mr. Evans]

Videos:

Spoiler: show

[Ulises]

His response is outdate imo, he need an improovemnt here, 82, could be?¿

IMO he deserves as well a bit higher TW he base his game on his speed and mainly in good links with his mates so i think that we can increase it to 85, or even higher but i don't want to overrate him, so say if you think it could be higher.

And i think that his low weight/weight makes him to be even more weak ingame, so i think we can raise a bit his balance to compensate this. Just 75, 1 point under iniesta, or even on par with him, 76.

And i think *Reaction is needed as well...

Suming up for the most lazy ones:
BB: 75/76.
RESP: 82.
TW: 85.
*Reaction

[Markulur]

Agree.

[as_10]

agree

BTW, as i said in the DA ladder, his DA should go up, to something like 87-88(prefer the first). I dont think hes worse than Sneijder or Riera

EDIT: shouldnt he has *passing or *playmaking?

[Ulises]

Well i add as_10 suggestion, and yes probably he would deserve *passing, but never *playmaking. Also make TW suggestion 1 poit higher, 86:


BB: 75-76.
RESP: 82.
DA: 87
TW: 86.
*Passing
*Reaction

Agrees: Pazza interista, as_10, ulises, ¿Mark?

[Dino]

BB: 75-76.
RESP: 82.
DA: 87
TW: 86.
*Passing
*Reaction

Agree

[Ulises]

BB: 75-76.
RESP: 82.
DA: 87
TW: 86.
*Passing
*Reaction

Agree

Done mate

[Markulur]

Updated.

SP can be high for sure. At least 85 if not more.

[Dino]

Updated.

SP can be high for sure. At least 85 if not more.

Agree with that.

[Ulises]

Updated.

SP can be high for sure. At least 85 if not more.

I don't think he can shot harder than higuain f.e. i disagree higher than 83... Also we can rise his ST i feel he should be in yellow numbers.

And also delete *dribbling, imo he doesn't dribble for fun, he is not "selfish" about dribbling.

[Markulur]

About ST agree. For sure he can be in yellow numbers... shoting being marked with an incredible accuracy.
About *Dribbling... well, he tries to dribble in lots of ocasions so I'm not sure.

And about SP... can your Higuain do this?
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=hdPbKKjfvp8... Is only an example, but I think that not. Silva can shot harder.
And take a look for *Middle shooting for this man, because he deserves sure.

[Ulises]

About the shot, he shows much more accuracy than power in that shot. And well he is running with the ball through the goal, when a player his running with the ball has more power at performing shots, that's why player take "carrerilla" to shot in FKs. And higuain has scored from outside sometimes with hard shots and without taking carrerilla. (how do you say carrerilla in english?¿ LOL).

What about ST: 82?¿

Also agree with *middle shoting.

And really rate as you want his SP, i won't agree with higher than 83, but don't take this as an disagree, you know what i think about this, and i don't want to discuss or disagree with you, cause you will get angry, and that would be worse for the forum and for the stats.

But anyway higuain forgets about accuracy and bases his shots in the power, you can see a video as well: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=atYNyW5e2Bs

[HitMan]

definitely agree with SP: 85 he has a very powerful shot, he showed that back at the Euro...he was shooting alot, and i also think he might be a good candidate for *Middle Shooting

btw. wtf is carrerilla ?

[Ulises]

I couldn't translate it sry... carrerilla is the little run that player take when they are going to perform a FK

[HitMan]

i dont know how to say it in english either..
but look at SILVA goal tonight http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_HrprN8HC34 he deserves the SP

[Ulises]

I saw the whole match... yeah really good goal, but i still think he shouldn't be over higuain, silva could be more accurate shoting from distance, perfectly suited by *middle shoting but i doubt he can shot as powerfull as higuain, who always applies hard power in every shots, even when he is in front of the GK, he belives more in power than in accuracy. Yes TBH i also think that he deserves the shot power, but also higuain, so making a fair comparation i can't agree in silva and forget about the other player.

But anyway, as i said before rate as you want i don't want people to get angry with me... So i am neutral about SP rate as you want...

[fishdalf]

Silva looks great, he really is pretty accurate. The only thing that bugs me however is his aggression. I believe it needs raising a few points as he gets forward an awful lot, somewhere between 84 and 86 wouldn't look out of place.

[fishdalf]

1 of 3 thing's:

1. My suggestion wasn't seen
2. It was and was ignored
3. Someone dissagrees

[Markulur]

Yepp!! First option... Probably a 85 can be the best point. So agree.

[fishdalf]

I'm even more convinced of mthe value after playing as Valencia about 30 times in the last 4 days lol. He definately doesn't get forward quite as much as he does in real life. Well, until 1 more agree...