Celtic All Stars

[Jez]

CELTIC ALL STARS

Goalkeepers:

Ronnie SIMPSON
John THOMSON
Packie BONNER


Defenders:

Billy MCNEILL
Bobby EVANS
Willie MCSTAY
Alec MCNAIR
Joe DODDS
Danny MCGRAIN
Tommy GEMMELL
Dan DOYLE


Midfielders:

Neil LENNON
Roy AITKEN
Bobby MURDOCH
Paul MCSTAY
Bertie AULD
George CONNELLY
Tommy BURNS
Adam MCLEAN
Charlie TULLY
Jimmy JOHNSTONE


Attackers:

Bobby LENNOX
Patsy GALLACHER
John HUGHES
Jimmy MCMENEMY
Kenny DALGLISH
Stevie CHALMERS
Sandy MCMAHON
John HARTSON
Jimmy QUINN
Henrik LARSSON
Jimmy MCGRORY


Best ever XI

--------------------------SIMPSON--------------------------
--------------------------------------------------------------
------------------------MCNEILL (c)------------------------
----MCGRAIN--------------------------------GEMMELL----
---------------------------------------------------------------
-----------------MURDOCH----------AULD-----------------
------------------------MCSTAY-----------------------------
----JOHNSTONE-------------------------------LENNOX----
--------------------------------------------------------------
-----------------LARSSON-----DALGLISH-----------------

[clinon]

Thx

But no John Hartson?

[Jez]

as i said in the description i wasn't sure where modern players ranked alongside those of the past
who would you remove for Hartson?

[clinon]

Oh sry I didn't read it.

I would remove Frank McGarvey or Willie Fernie

[Jez]

done
I'm just waiting for the inevitable "where the hell is ...... and ....... and .......!?!" haha

[clinon]

I think you can do a list of reserves

There I would put in:

Artur Boruc
Shunsuke Nakamaura
Frank McGarvey
Chris Sutton

[clinon]

What about Jackie McNamara instead of Bobo Balde?

Balde could be moved to reserves.

[prosser2k10]

good work jez m8 but as these teams have players on what they did for theyre club not theyre name i think my m8 would have some suggestions i'll ask him hes a celtic fan and what about the guy who scored theyre first ever goal i think he was rather prolific i dont know his name but my m8 does as he gave me a history lesson in celtic

[Paddy]

Where's Du Wei and Adam Virgo?

[clinon]

Tommy Gemmell:

60-s/tommy-gemmell-1966-1970-t12731.html

Bertie Auld:

60-s/bertie-auld-1962-1970-t12756.html

Neil Lennon:

00-s/neil-lennon-2000-2003-t12626.html

Stevie Chalmers:

60-s/stevie-chalmers-1963-1968-t12763.html

[Giff]

Charlie Tully should be also on this list.

[Cold_Mac]

I got a slightly different all star team than this.

GOALKEEPERS

Ronnie SIMPSON
John THOMSON
Packie BONNER

DEFENDERS

Danny McGRAIN
Tommy GEMMELL
Billy McNEIL
Bobby EVANS
Joe DODDS
Alec McNAIR
Danny DOYLE
Willie McSTAY

MIDFIELDERS

James YOUNG
Bobby MURDOCH
Paul McSTAY
Bertie AULD
Jimmy JOHNSTONE
Bobby LENNOX
Patsy GALLACHER
Adam McCLEAN
Roy AITKEN
Charlie TULLY
Malky MacDONALD
George CONNELLY
Jimmy DELANEY

ATTACKERS

Chris SUTTON
Henrik LARSSON
Kenny DALGLISH
Jimmy MCGRORY
Stevie CHALMERS
Sandy MCMAHON
Jimmy McMENEMY
Jimmy QUINN

I could create the player-sets I use.

[paddypoohead]

Where is Lubo Moravcik?

[Sean_19]

Really interesting team, It would be really great if someone could create the missing players especially Willie McStay, Charlie Tully, Jimmy Quinn and, most of all "Big Dan Doyle" (He MUST be Left back in the Best Ever XI!).
And what about David and James Hay or "Sniper" James McColl?

[Cold_Mac]

Yes, could make them as well as Sunny Jim Young, Gilchrist (brillant passing player from the 20's with Barton-esque antics) and his successor Peter Wilson.
I have the Alphabet of the Celts and various other sources to build reasons for my different and I'm certainly not an overpowering fan-boy.

I'll post them in the future.

[Sean_19]

Brilliant mate!

[Brezza]

I'd be interested in seeing Charlie Tully.

[patrick88]

would love for someone to have a bash at a few of the bhoys

[KeyserSoze]

Don't you think there must be a place for Slovakian legend Lubo Moravcik?