Ajacied_Breda1 wrote:Personally, I rate Thiago Silva as a defender in the sentence of "good". He's good enough for Serie A and against some Champions League sides but he won't be able to be compared to the standard Milan set a time ago I feel. Still a very capable defender that wouldn't go amiss in many CL-sides that sit outside of the usual title-favourite zone.
Also, having Nesta by your side aids you very, very much. Even though the experienced beast at the back didn't have a good game yesterday by any means.
DeFrenZ wrote:TS could go up to 84 imo
DeFrenZ wrote:You DO know that "clearing" headers need something like 60 HEA? everything more is for making passes and most importantly shots.
DeFrenZ wrote:True, JMP is needed. But since you proposed both with the same "motive"... all your suggestion lost value
Though i don't really know what his JMP value should be, so I'm okay with the one here right now
Kris wrote:why is his shot power 90?
DeFrenZ wrote:If those are his hardest shots... then he can sit on 85
the thing that impresses me is that both are on the corner of the net.
zuo wrote:i can't agree to an HEA raise,cause in my opinion 83 is a fine value that shows his decent heading ability. putting him at any higher value,for now,would imo be a ladder disrespecting. simple people like Simone Inzaghi or Portanova are still more valuable headers than him.
as said before,id agree to a reasonable JMP update,cause i remember well that the duel with him and Lucarelli was on the same level that the duel with Nesta and Lucarelli(both consistently beaten by livorno's CF) but nesta is 4 cm taller.
also,nowadays Nesta can't be over a 79 JMP for what he showed.
id say that an 86 JMP for T.Silva would be enough,with a really border line 87(imo Melo's JMP last year was a tad more impressive [same height])
Att: 64/65(kris) 65(becks)
Defense: 83(becks) 84(pedela)(tamaguchi) 85(aurandon)(metro)
Top Speed: 82/83(zuo) 83(metro)(becks) 83/84(pedela) 84(braslianfan)(defrenz)(master)(fledarr)
Acceleration: 81/82(zuo) 84(becks)(pedela)(tamaguchi) 85(braslianfan)(metro)
Response: 83(braslianfan) 84(becks) 85(metro)(pedela)(tamaguchi)(master) 86(aurandon) disagree85(zuo)
Agility: 77(metro)(becks) 79(aurandon) 81(braslianfan)(pedela)
Dribbling Accuracy: 73(metro) 75(becks) 77(crnogorac)
Dribbling Speed: 75(master)(metro) 76(tamaguchi) 76/77(zuo) 77(becks)
Short Pass Accuracy: 74(metro)(braslianfan)(pedela)(fevernova) 75(becks)
Short Pass Speed: 72(metro) 73(becks)(fevernova) 75(braslianfan)(pedela)
Long Pass Acc.: 73(braslianfan)(pedela) 74(metro) 75(becks)(fevernova) 76(tamaguchi)(jmg721) 77(metro) 80(aurandon)(crnogorac)
Long Pass Speed: 74(braslianfan)(pedela)(becks) 75(metro) 77(fevernova) 79(tamaguchi)(jmg721)(metro) 82/83(aurandon)
Shot Acc: 68(becks)
Shot Power: 87(becks)(master?)(dsc)(kris?) 88(tamaguchi)
Shot Tech: 70(becks)
Free Kick Acc: 73(tamaguchi) 74(becks)
Header: 83(becks)(alex)(zuo)(jimboi) 84(metro)(master)(pedala) 85/86(fledarr) 86(tamaguchi)
Jumping: 84(becks) 86(metro)(tamaguchi)(zuo)(jimboi)(pedala) 86/87(fledarr) 87(master)(alex)
Technique: 75(pedela)(metro)(marcus)(tamaguchi)(zuo) 76(becks)
Team Work: 80(metro)(becks) disagree(rfuna)
Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 3 guests