Balance, in relation to Height/Weight

Moderator: Mod's

Balance, in relation to Height/Weight

Postby DeFrenZ » 2009 Feb 05, 00:35

We all agree that a player's power is influenced by BB as much as by it's Height and Weight... so the discussion is about "IF really do these stats make the difference" and, if yes, "HOW MUCH do these stats make the difference" ;)

BB for small players should be discussed here too, imo.

Image Italy
Image Juventus F.C.
User avatar
DeFrenZ
 
Posts: 1523
Joined: 2008 Dec 08, 20:15
Location: Italy
Has thanked: 0 time
Been thanked: 1 time

by »



 

Re: Balance, in relation to Height/Weight

Postby jmg721 » 2009 Feb 05, 01:17

I guess that works. For guys similar height who I've seen in the last 24 ours, I'd put him maybe slightly above Cossu(73), on par with Pisano(77), above Esposito(73), below Di Vaio(73), above Sculli(76), above Mascara(73) and Marchionni(73).

I did this before looking at Height & weight, and their current Bal values. Here is my conclusion of this group:
Franco BRIENZA 168/70 - 76
Andrea COSSU 171/63 - 73
Francesco PISANO 174/67 - 76 or 77
Marco MARCHIONNI 175/66 - 73 or 74 (got to see him head to head with Pisano)
Mauro ESPOSITO 172/71 - 71 or 72
Marco DI VAIO 179/78(really :shock:) - 75 or 76
Giuseppe MASCARA 175(yeah right! :lol:)/66 - 73
Giuseppe SCULLI 177/71 - 74 or 75

Other guys while I'm at it:
Davide CARRUS 170/67 - (75)
Sebastian GIOVINCO 164/59( :o ) - (73) - looking at this and considering the size difference b/n him and Mascara makes me agree his Bal will eventually need to be improved
Alessandro DEL PIERO 173/73 - (78)
Mauro ZARATE 173/68 - (77)
Pasquale FOGGIA 172/71(yeah right :roll: ) - (70) - should be 1 or 2 points below Esposito
Andrea ARDITO 172/61 - (74)
Walter GARGANO 168/65 - (76) - comapring him to Brienza, who should have the higher Bal?
Fabrizio MICCOLI 168/64 - (79) - probably could be closer to 81 w/ Simplicio being 171/75 - (82)
Luca VIGIANI 180/74 - (74) - Looks more justified now that you see how much bigger he is, and he hits the deck more than a lot of these guys.
Carlos CARMONA 168/68 - (78) - plays bigger than his height and weight.
Vincenzo MONTELLA 172/71 - (69) if he is that, than what is Foggia :shock:
CICINHO 172/68 - (76)
David PIZARRO 170/65 - (78)
Camilo ZUÑIGA 172/72 - (74)
Alessandro ROSINA 168/65 - (78) - There were cries for even higher, and looking on here I think they have a point. Slight player, but doesn't go down easily
Marco PISANO 174/75 - (77) - gotta be the smallest CB
Alexis SÁNCHEZ 170/69 - (74)
Antonio DI NATALE 170/70 - (77)

"The Recoba Effect"
User avatar
jmg721
 
Posts: 5518
Joined: 2008 Dec 08, 23:47
Location: Chicago, Illinois
Has thanked: 0 time
Been thanked: 0 time

Re: Balance, in relation to Height/Weight

Postby coolactive » 2009 Feb 05, 12:30

Just a thought...

If you give smaller and lighter (let's say SCULLI 177/71) players bigger BB imo it should be, then ,related to decrease in theirs STAMINA - I am almost sure they will lost much power in fighting with stronger players to stay on their feet. So, they will tire faster, loose more "juice".

People, what do you think ?

http://www.fcradnicki-nis.com/
FK Radnički Niš Stadium Reconstruction : http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=mVC8KPA70hM
User avatar
coolactive
 
Posts: 2281
Joined: 2008 Dec 23, 07:10
Location: Niš, South Serbia
Has thanked: 2 times
Been thanked: 3 times

Re: Balance, in relation to Height/Weight

Postby PMC » 2009 Feb 05, 19:09

I just think of Dani Alves... despite his size hes got 82 BB and he can easily shield the ball against strong guys in my game and wins many physical challenges even against guys who are much taller than him

I'm against you
User avatar
PMC
 
Posts: 6728
Joined: 2008 Dec 08, 19:51
Location: Vienna
Has thanked: 6 times
Been thanked: 7 times

Re: Balance, in relation to Height/Weight

Postby Playboy » 2009 Feb 21, 15:01

PMC wrote:I just think of Dani Alves... despite his size hes got 82 BB and he can easily shield the ball against strong guys in my game and wins many physical challenges even against guys who are much taller than him


In reality that's because he has wide body ( wide shoulders and overall great body muscle and fitness )

Playboy
 
Posts: 210
Joined: 2008 Dec 25, 11:50
Has thanked: 0 time
Been thanked: 0 time

Re: Balance, in relation to Height/Weight

Postby Erevos » 2009 Mar 07, 20:24

Just a weird question... if i decrease height by 15 to all players, how much i have to decrease their weight to look like before and just be smaller? and do i have to change their balance and stamina to?

Erevos
 
Posts: 8
Joined: 2009 Feb 24, 20:53
Has thanked: 0 time
Been thanked: 0 time


Return to Attributes analysed and explained

Who is online

Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 2 guests