Starting with Balance . We all know that the player who has balance is focusing on both Attack and defence . Balance was replaced by
but for sure the first one is more effective and players like Essien and some strikers who usually chase back . Also some defenders who go forward every time they get the chance to attack like David Luiz and sides back .
Def was also replaced by
I believe that many CBs deserve the first one because they know when they attack and when they shouldn't . Also it's working well with SBs and DMFs who are focusing on defending more than attacking .
About the second one , I think it works very well with GoalKeepers and defenders who rarely participate in attack .
Off was replaced by
middlefielders like Ribery and Di Maria deserve the first one because they attack and try to defend when they should go back and help the defenders . Some sides back also deserves this awareness and some strikers . I think Ronaldo deserves the second because he doesn't defend that much to deserve 2 for def but surely he deserves the 3 for atk . Also it's very good with strikers who don't try to chase back .
S/OFF and S/DEF .
I always believe that players who look so lazy should get this card and not the players who are so active at attack or defence . So I think S/OFF is equal to
atk : 2
and S/Def is equal to
When I started to write this topic my Aim was updating players who have a wrong atk and def awareness on PSD .